Counting by Numbers – China’s Shinewing expands

June 29, 2015

MEETING client needs in Australia and China is an enduring need for both China accounting major, ShineWing, and the Melbourne accounting firm, Moore Stephens, as they watch the burgeoning increase in two-way trade and investment between the two countries . . .

THE timing was fortuitous when China’s leading home-grown accounting firm, Shine-Wing, approached Moore Stephens Melbourne 14 months ago for a potential tie-up.
The Australian firm was in the midst of considering its options in moving forward to offer both national and international capability in accounting and financial services to its clients.
ShineWing China, which already had an office in Melbourne, was seeking a bigger footprint in Australia to tap into the opportunities thrown up by a sharp rise in Chinese investment. ShineWing initially had been collaborating with Australia’s Hall Chadwick (ATI April 2012), but that association has since been abandoned.
The upshot was that Moore Stephens Melbourne and ShineWing agreed to form a single entity bearing the shingle of ShineWing Australia to further their shared ambitions.
Marco Carlei, Managing Partner and then-Head of Moore Stephens Melbourne —  now Managing Partner of the enlarged ShineWing Australia — says his firm’s strategic vision for its future reflects the needs of its clients.
“More and more we were finding that our clients were looking to explore opportunities outside Australia, particularly in China,” he told ATI. “We wanted to be able to facilitate, where we could, our clients’ strategic ambitions.
“We realised we needed to have an Asian strategy, and that it would have to be more than mere lip-service. We needed to establish a strong relationship with a Chinese firm, accepting the impact of China on the Australian economy, on our clients’ businesses, and on our own firm.”
Following the approach from ShineWing, Moore Stephens Melbourne did its own research and concluded that its strategic vision could best be achieved by being part of ShineWing International — more-so than
remaining with Moore Stephens International, based out of London.
Carlei says: “ShineWing China is a national practice and we saw that as a favourable attribute — one that is very important to us.
“It is a firm with 19 offices and a staff of 4,500.  That is important because, if a client of ours wants to explore possibilities in Shanghai, Beijing and Guangzhou, we need to deal with one or two partners in ShineWing China and not have to deal with independent firms.”
ShineWing was started by Zhang Ke, a former Managing Partner of Coopers & Lybrand in China. Zhang left C&L when the firm merged with Price Waterhouse to become PricewaterhouseCoopers in 1999, and has since been
described as having more influence within Corporate China than the heads of the big four global accounting firms operating there.
“We could see opportunities for all stakeholders,” Carlei told ATI. “We appreciate and know that it is also important for ShineWing to have capability in Australia. ShineWing China has a very impressive international client list. It represents a number of SOEs (State-owned enterprises) in China, and these have subsidiaries elsewhere, including in Australia.”
It has been reported that ShineWing counts at least 10 per cent of China’s SOEs on its client list. One of these is Yancoal – a ShineWing client both in China and Australia.
Spectacular business growth had seen ShineWing outgrow its offshore capabilities, Carlei says, and it had realised it needed to enhance its capabilities outside China.
Carlei has proposed that ShineWing China deploy staff to Australia to boost the Australian firm’s China capability when working with the subsidiaries of Chinese SOEs.  
 “ShineWing China has strong relationships and experience working with Chinese companies,” he says. “So it makes sense for us to solicit their support and input because they
understand the mindset of a client’s management and that clients’ senior executives back in China.  More often than not, these are the ones dictating to the managements in their subsidiaries.”
He adds: “It is important that we have a close relationship with ShineWing China. If we don’t have this relationship, we may overlook some key issues and important objectives of our Chinese clients.”
On fees, Carlei says whenever ShineWing Australia works for a subsidiary of Chinese companies in Australia, it will be paid by the subsidiary.
“Fundamentally, our relationship is to make money together. We don’t want to make money off each other. ShineWing does not expect to take a financial stake in our firm, and we don’t want to take a financial interest in theirs.
“Our relationship with ShineWing is that we are part of ShineWing International, just as ShineWing China is part of ShingWing International. That is the extent of our financial relationship. We are part of an internationally-federated model.”
Carlei adds that ShineWing Australia’s partners have total control of the firm’s business and its strategic plans. A key part of the firm’s vision is to have a financially integrated network of offices in Australia – no different to ShineWing China, where partners own the network of offices in China.
ShineWing Australia will fund its own expansion in Australia to establish a national network of offices. It opened its Sydney office, in Macquarie Street, in April.
Carlei says the firm has clients in other States – NSW, Queensland and Western Australia. He has been to Brisbane to meet clients and plans to have an office established there within six months. There are also plans to set up a presence in Adelaide and Perth.
In recent years, Moore Stephens Melbourne has grown rapidly – and organically. Significantly, Carlei says the firm has been able to fund its growth from its own resources internally, without having to resort to debt.
 This has been made possible, he says, by the firm’s ability to successfully clinch big jobs in recent years, allowing it to build up reserves.
“We will be a $50 million fee turnover practice this year — twice the size we were five years ago,” Carlei told ATI. The enlarged firm has 30 partners and a staff of 250.
“We have cherry-picked certain Partners of other firms to join our firm,” say Carlei. For example, Colin Radford, our senior Government consulting partner,  and Jason Crawford, who is in charge of research and development and Government grants — were both previously with Deloitte. We also secured Clive Bird, Senior Tax Partner from Grant Thornton. They were all national lead Partners in their former firms, but chose to join us because they share our aspiration for growth — and want to be part of that future.”
Initially, Carlei had hoped to pursue his ambition of forming a financially integrated network with other Moore Stephens firms in Australia. These operate on a federated system — as does the global operation of Moore Stephens — but other network members did not share his vision or aspirations for the firm — at least not in the short term.
Moore Stephens Melbourne could see the challenges ahead as long as the firm remained part of a federated network where other member firms did not share its amibitions.
Unprepared to wait, Carlei struck out on his own — forging the link with ShineWing. He says this positions ShineWing Australia as a credible alternative offering a depth of capabilities and a wider range of services to global
accounting houses and second-tier firms.